Introduction

Choosing the right school for your child is one of the most important decisions you'll make as a parent. Whether your child is entering kindergarten, transitioning to middle or high school, or you're relocating to a new area, finding a school that meets your child's unique needs requires careful research and consideration.

School choice options have expanded dramatically in recent years, giving families more educational alternatives than ever before. According to GreatSchools.org, nearly half of all preK-12 households in the United States research schools online each year. With so many options available, having a systematic approach to finding and evaluating schools is essential.

This guide will walk you through:

  • Understanding the different types of schools available
  • Using data and ratings effectively (and understanding their limitations)
  • Preparing for and conducting school visits
  • Asking the right questions to determine fit
  • Making your final decision

• • •

Understanding Your School Options

Before diving into the evaluation process, it's important to understand the main types of schools available to families. Each type has distinct characteristics, benefits, and considerations.

Traditional Public Schools

Public schools are funded by local, state, and federal taxes and are open to all students within a designated district. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, the vast majority of American students—approximately 50 million—attend public schools.

Key characteristics:

  • Free to attend with no tuition costs
  • Must accept all students within district boundaries
  • Teachers are required to be state-certified
  • Must provide special education services under federal law (IDEA)
  • Subject to state curriculum standards and standardized testing

Charter Schools

Charter schools are publicly funded but independently operated. They emerged in the 1990s with the goal of providing educational innovation while remaining accountable to performance standards outlined in their charter agreement.

Key characteristics:

  • Free to attend (publicly funded)
  • Operate independently from traditional school district oversight
  • Have flexibility in curriculum and teaching methods
  • Often use lottery-based admission due to high demand
  • Must meet the academic goals outlined in their charter
  • Some specialize in specific approaches (STEM, arts, language immersion)

Magnet Schools

Magnet schools are public schools with specialized curricula or themes designed to attract students from across a district. They originated in the late 1960s as a voluntary desegregation strategy and have evolved to offer distinctive educational programs.

Key characteristics:

  • Free to attend as part of the public school system
  • Focus on specific themes (STEM, performing arts, IB programs, etc.)
  • Draw students from beyond neighborhood boundaries
  • Often receive additional funding for specialized programs
  • May require applications, auditions, or entrance exams

Private Schools

Private schools are funded primarily through tuition and private sources rather than government funding. They operate independently and set their own admission criteria, curriculum, and educational philosophy.

Key characteristics:

  • Require tuition (though scholarships may be available)
  • Can set their own admission criteria
  • Not required to follow state curriculum standards
  • May offer religious or faith-based education
  • Often feature smaller class sizes
  • Not required to provide the same special education services as public schools

• • •

Using School Data and Ratings Wisely

School rating websites and government data can be valuable starting points in your research, but it's important to understand what these metrics measure—and what they don't.

Government Data Sources

The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) requires every state to maintain public report cards for schools and districts. These report cards include standardized test scores, graduation rates, teacher qualifications, school climate data, and per-pupil expenditures.

You can access your state's report card through the U.S. Department of Education's website, which provides links to all 50 state report card systems. These official sources offer reliable data collected under consistent standards.

Key metrics available in state report cards:

  • Student achievement on state assessments in reading, math, and science
  • Graduation rates
  • Student attendance and chronic absenteeism
  • Teacher qualifications and experience
  • School safety and discipline data
  • Per-pupil spending

Consumer Rating Websites

Websites like GreatSchools, Niche, and SchoolDigger provide ratings and reviews that can help you compare schools quickly. However, education researchers caution that these ratings have important limitations.

GreatSchools uses a 1-10 rating system based on student progress (growth), test score proficiency, and college readiness indicators. According to GreatSchools, ratings at the lower end (1-4) indicate below average performance, 5-6 indicate average, and 7-10 are above average.

Niche combines statistical data with user reviews to generate letter grades for schools. Their ratings factor in academics, diversity, teachers, and other categories based on available data and survey responses.

Understanding Rating Limitations

While rating websites can be helpful starting points, education experts urge parents to look beyond the numbers. Research has shown that school ratings correlate heavily with the socioeconomic status of the student body.

Important considerations:

  • Test scores reflect more than teaching quality. Standardized test performance correlates with family income, parent education levels, and other factors beyond the school's control.
  • Growth matters. Student progress ratings (how much students improve over time) may better reflect school effectiveness than raw proficiency scores. GreatSchools includes growth metrics, though proficiency rates still comprise the largest portion of their overall rating.
  • Ratings don't capture everything. School culture, extracurricular programs, social-emotional support, and individual teacher quality aren't fully reflected in numerical ratings.
  • Context matters. A school serving a high-poverty population may have lower test scores but still provide excellent instruction and support. Conversely, a school in an affluent area may have high scores primarily due to advantages students bring from home.

• • •

Visiting Schools: What to Look For

There's no substitute for visiting schools in person. A school that looks great on paper may not be the right fit for your child, while a lower-rated school might surprise you with its warmth, innovation, or particular strengths that match your child's needs.

Before Your Visit

Preparation will help you make the most of your school visit:

  1. Research the school beforehand. Review test scores, demographics, and any available information on the school's website.
  2. Prepare a list of questions. Write down what matters most to your family and what you want to learn.
  3. Bring something to take notes. You'll be absorbing a lot of information, and details can blur together after visiting multiple schools.
  4. Consider your child's needs. Think about learning style, interests, social needs, and any special requirements.

What to Observe During Your Visit

Pay attention to both formal presentations and informal observations:

Classroom Environment

  • Do classrooms look organized and inviting?
  • Is student work displayed, and does it seem appropriate for the grade level?
  • Are teachers engaged with students and asking questions that stimulate thinking?
  • Do students seem focused and engaged, or distracted and bored?

School Culture

  • How do students behave in hallways, the cafeteria, and on the playground?
  • How do staff interact with students—is there warmth and respect?
  • Does the principal seem present and connected to the school community?
  • What is the overall energy and atmosphere?

Facilities

  • Are facilities clean and well-maintained?
  • Are there adequate resources (library, computer lab, art room, gym)?
  • Does the building feel safe and secure?
  • Are outdoor spaces inviting and appropriate for students' ages?

• • •

Essential Questions to Ask

Asking the right questions will help you understand whether a school is the right fit for your child and family. Here are key questions organized by category.

Academic Program

  • What is the school's educational philosophy or mission, and how is it incorporated into daily learning?
  • What curriculum does the school use for core subjects?
  • How does the school support students who are advanced academically?
  • How does the school respond when a student is struggling to meet academic standards?
  • What is the school's homework philosophy, and how much homework can I expect at different grade levels?

Teachers and Staff

  • What are the qualifications and experience levels of the teaching staff?
  • What is the average class size and student-to-teacher ratio?
  • What professional development opportunities are provided to teachers?
  • What is the staff turnover rate, and what are common reasons teachers leave?

Student Support

  • What counseling or mental health resources are available to students?
  • How does the school support students with learning differences or special needs?
  • What is the school's approach to discipline and behavior management?
  • What anti-bullying policies and programs are in place?

Community and Culture

  • How engaged are parents in the school community?
  • What opportunities exist for parent involvement?
  • How does the school communicate with parents about student progress and school events?
  • How diverse is the student body, and how does the school celebrate or address diversity?

Practical Considerations

  • What time does the school day begin and end?
  • Is before- and after-school care available?
  • What transportation options are available?
  • What extracurricular activities, sports, and clubs are offered?
  • For private schools: What is the total cost including tuition, fees, and additional expenses?

• • •

Special Considerations

Children with Learning Differences

If your child has a learning difference, disability, or special need, additional research is essential. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), public schools and charter schools must provide free appropriate public education (FAPE) to all eligible students, including evaluations and Individualized Education Programs (IEPs).

Key questions for families of children with special needs:

  • What special education services and programs does the school offer?
  • Are students with learning differences integrated into general classrooms or in separate settings?
  • What is the school's experience with your child's specific needs?
  • How many special education staff members does the school employ, and what are their qualifications?
  • What is the process for requesting an evaluation or updating an IEP?

Note that private schools are not required to provide the same special education services as public schools. If considering private school for a child with special needs, carefully investigate what support they offer.

Gifted and Advanced Learners

If your child is academically advanced, look for schools with robust programs to keep them challenged:

  • Does the school offer gifted and talented programs?
  • How does the school differentiate instruction for advanced learners in regular classrooms?
  • Are acceleration options available (subject-level or grade-level)?
  • For high schools: What Advanced Placement (AP), International Baccalaureate (IB), or dual enrollment courses are offered?

• • •

Making Your Decision

After researching and visiting schools, you'll need to synthesize everything you've learned to make a decision. Here's a framework to help.

Prioritize What Matters Most

Every family has different priorities. Before making a final decision, rank what matters most to you:

  • Academic rigor and curriculum quality
  • School culture and values alignment
  • Extracurricular offerings
  • Location and convenience
  • Diversity and inclusion
  • Special programs or support services
  • Cost (for private schools)

Consider Your Child's Perspective

When age-appropriate, involve your child in the decision. Ask them about their impressions from school visits. Consider their personality: Would they thrive in a large, bustling school or a smaller, more intimate setting? Do they need more structure or more freedom to explore?

Trust Your Instincts

Data and ratings are valuable tools, but they don't tell the whole story. Your intuition as a parent matters. If a school feels right—if you can picture your child happy and thriving there—that's meaningful information.

Conversely, if something feels off during your visit, even if you can't articulate exactly what, trust that feeling. The best school for your child is one where they will be known, supported, challenged, and happy.

• • •

Conclusion

Finding the right school for your child takes time and effort, but the investment is worthwhile. By understanding your options, using data wisely, visiting schools, asking thoughtful questions, and considering your child's unique needs, you can make an informed decision that sets your child up for success.

Remember that school choice is not a one-time decision. As your child grows and their needs change, you may revisit this process at transition points. Stay engaged with your child's education, maintain open communication with teachers and administrators, and remain willing to advocate for what your child needs.

The best school for your child is one that recognizes their potential, supports their growth, and helps them develop into a confident, capable, and curious learner.

• • •

Additional Resources

Government Resources

School Rating Websites

Special Education Resources