The email arrives in February, as they always do: lottery applications for the local charter school are open. Your neighbor's kids go there and seem to be thriving. A colleague raves about the arts program. But your daughter has been at the neighborhood elementary since kindergarten, and she loves her teacher, and her best friend lives three doors down. You find yourself staring at the application deadline, wondering if you're making a decision or avoiding one.

This moment of uncertainty—standing at the crossroads of educational choice—is one that millions of American parents face each year. Charter school enrollment has grown steadily over the past two decades, with roughly 3.7 million students now attending these publicly funded, independently operated schools. Yet for every family who discovers their child blossoming in a charter environment, there's another who finds the traditional public school down the street was the right choice all along.

The research, while informative, won't make this decision for you. What it can do—and what we'll try to do here—is help you ask the right questions.

• • •

The data on charter schools has become more robust in recent years, and the picture it paints is nuanced. Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes, in its most comprehensive study to date, examined student performance across 31 states and found that charter school students gained the equivalent of 16 additional days of learning in reading and 6 in math compared to their peers in traditional public schools. The gains were particularly notable for Black and Hispanic students and those from low-income families.

But here's where honest reporting requires some caveats. Critics, including researchers at the National Education Policy Center, point out that these differences, while statistically significant, are quite small in practical terms—less than a tenth of a standard deviation. And there's enormous variation within the charter sector itself. Some charter schools dramatically outperform their local traditional schools; others significantly underperform. The Stanford researchers themselves noted that virtual charter schools showed "strongly negative outcomes." Performance, as education consultant Pierre Huguet has observed, "really depends on the individual school, its leadership and its approach." The takeaway isn't that charter schools are categorically better or worse. It's that the specific school matters far more than the sector.

• • •

Before you can evaluate any school, you have to start with your child. This sounds obvious, but parents often skip this step, jumping straight to test scores and reputation without first articulating what their particular child actually needs.

Consider learning style. Some children thrive in highly structured environments with clear expectations and uniform discipline. Others need more flexibility, more movement, more creative latitude. Many charter schools emphasize one approach or another—classical education with its focus on great texts and Socratic discussion, or project-based learning with its emphasis on collaboration and real-world application. Neither is inherently superior; the question is which aligns with how your child actually learns.

Then there's the matter of temperament. A shy child might flourish in the smaller, more intimate community that many charter schools offer, where teachers are more likely to know every student by name. Or that same child might feel more comfortable in the larger traditional school where there's more social cover, more room to find their people gradually. An intensely social child might love the tight-knit culture of a mission-driven charter—or feel constrained by it.

Dr. Lauren Morando Rhim, co-founder of the Center for Learner Equity, notes that for children with learning differences, the decision requires particular care. Charter schools are legally required to provide special education services—they're public schools, after all—but capacity and expertise vary widely. Some charter schools have built exceptional programs for students with learning disabilities; the percentage of students with IEPs in charter schools has grown from 10.4 percent in 2012 to 11.5 percent in 2021. But that rate still lags behind traditional public schools, where 14.1 percent of students receive special education services. If your child has an IEP, you'll want to ask detailed questions about how services are delivered, who provides them, and what the school's track record looks like for students with similar needs.

• • •

Here's where the conversation shifts from the aspirational to the practical. A school can have a beautiful mission and outstanding teachers and still be wrong for your family if the logistics don't work.

Transportation is the issue that trips up the most families. Only 16 states require charter schools to provide transportation, and even in those states, the reality can be complicated. A 2024 report from HopSkipDrive found that 62 percent of parents have missed work because of school transportation needs, and that figure tends to be higher for families choosing schools outside their neighborhood. Charter school advocates acknowledge this burden. "A family can't choose a school if their children can't get there," notes the National Association of Charter School Authorizers.

Think honestly about your family's capacity. Will one parent need to leave work early every day for pickup? What happens when there's a sick day, or a snow day, or an after-school activity that runs late? If you have multiple children, consider whether the logistics multiply—different schools with different schedules can turn a manageable commute into daily chaos. EdChoice research found that for families earning under $30,000 annually, 63 percent rated transportation as "extremely or very important" in their school decision, compared to 41 percent of families earning over $100,000. This isn't a matter of caring less; it's a matter of having fewer buffers when logistics fail.

And then there are siblings. Your neighborhood school guarantees that all your children can attend together. Charter schools typically offer sibling preference in their lottery, but it's not guaranteed, and timing matters. If your eldest is already enrolled and thriving, the calculus is different than if you're starting fresh with your youngest and hoping older siblings can transfer in later.

• • •

Every school choice involves trade-offs, and charter schools are no exception. Understanding what you might gain and what you might lose can help you make a clearer-eyed decision.

The potential benefits are real. Many charter schools offer specialized focuses—STEM, arts, classical education, language immersion—that may not be available at your neighborhood school. The smaller size of many charters (the average charter school enrolls fewer students than the average traditional public school) often translates to closer teacher-student relationships and a stronger sense of community. Parents at charter schools consistently report higher satisfaction rates than parents at assigned district schools, according to surveys from the U.S. Department of Education and Education Next. Charter parents are, on average, 13 percentage points more satisfied across measures of teacher quality, discipline, expectations, safety, and character education.

But the potential drawbacks deserve equal consideration. Extracurricular activities, particularly athletics, can be limited. As of 2017, only about 40 percent of charter schools nationwide offered interscholastic sports, compared to more than 80 percent of traditional public schools. Smaller schools often struggle to field teams, lack facilities, and face bureaucratic hurdles in athletic associations. Some states have begun addressing this—Florida recently passed legislation allowing charter students to participate in private school sports programs if their own school doesn't offer the sport—but gaps remain.

There's also the question of stability. The charter sector operates on a market model, which means schools that don't attract enough students or meet their academic targets can close. A 2024 report from the Network for Public Education found that more than one in four charter schools close within five years, and by the 20-year mark, 55 percent have shuttered. Nearly half of closures between 2022 and 2024 happened with little advance warning—during the school year or over summer. This doesn't mean your child's charter school will close. Many are well-established and thriving. But it does mean the stability that traditional public schools offer—the near-certainty that the school will still exist next year—isn't quite as guaranteed.

• • •

Charter schools are often mission-driven in ways that traditional public schools, which must serve all comers with a general mandate, cannot be. This can be a significant draw—or a source of friction.

Take a hard look at what the school actually values, not just what its marketing materials say. Visit during a regular school day. Watch how teachers interact with struggling students. Ask about discipline policies and what happens when a child doesn't fit the mold. Some charter schools have built cultures of warmth and high expectations that bring out the best in children. Others have strict discipline codes that work beautifully for some families and feel punitive to others. Neither approach is wrong; the question is whether it's right for your child and consistent with your family's values.

Research on school choice consistently shows that parents don't always know what factors will ultimately matter most to them. A 2024 study published in PLOS ONE found that parents' stated priorities often didn't match their revealed preferences—the factors they said were important predicted different choices than the factors that actually drove their decisions. The parent who insists they're focused on academic rigor might ultimately choose the school with the friendliest principal. This isn't hypocrisy; it's human nature. When you visit schools, pay attention to your gut reactions as well as your checklist.

• • •

In the conversation about school choice, the assigned neighborhood school sometimes gets treated as the default—the thing you're choosing away from. But that framing isn't fair. Your neighborhood school has genuine advantages worth considering.

Proximity matters more than we sometimes acknowledge. Children who attend nearby schools can walk or bike, building independence and getting exercise. They make friends who live on the same block, friendships that extend naturally into after-school play and weekend hangouts. Parents connect with other parents at drop-off; the school becomes a center of community life. There's no scramble for transportation, no stress when you're running five minutes late.

There's also something to be said for the stability and comprehensiveness of district schools. Traditional public schools must accept all students, provide transportation, offer full special education services, and maintain programs regardless of enrollment fluctuations. They're accountable to elected school boards and subject to extensive public oversight. When a district school has problems, there are established mechanisms for parents to advocate for change.

Before you write off your neighborhood school, give it a fair look. Tour the campus. Meet the principal. Talk to parents whose children attend. You may find that the school's reputation doesn't match its reality—for better or worse. And remember that you can be involved in making your neighborhood school better. Parents who invest energy in their local school often find that energy returned many times over.

• • •

The decision about where to send your child to school is one of the weightier ones you'll make as a parent. It shapes their days, their friendships, their sense of themselves as learners. It affects your family's schedule, your community connections, your daily stress levels. There's a reason it keeps parents up at night.

But here's the reassuring truth that research consistently reveals: most children can thrive in a variety of educational settings. The specific school matters less than having parents who are engaged, teachers who care, and an environment where the child feels safe and known. A charter school might provide that. So might your neighborhood school. The best choice is the one that fits your particular child and your particular family—not the one that sounds best on paper or impresses the neighbors.

If you do apply to a charter school and don't get in, that's not a tragedy. If you choose your neighborhood school and later wonder about the road not taken, that's normal. Children are resilient, and good parenting matters more than perfect school selection. What matters is that you're asking these questions at all—that you're thinking carefully about your child's education and advocating for what they need. That's the most important choice you've already made.

Sources